On Choosing a Family Car: Brand New vs. Second-Hand

There are many things married couples should look into and decide on: family home, child’s education, how to raise kids, savings account, and yes, a family car.

A family car. 

Personally, I do not consider car as an investment. The moment it steps out of the casa, the value immediately depreciates. Once you decide to sell it, you won’t be able to earn from it and could even get less than 50 percent than its original price. Don’t even get me started with maintenance costs. Although I know nothing about cars and the mechanisms involved, I do know that it entails costs. Big costs depending on the car brand. 

Let’s face it: with the current condition, it’s hard and less convenient to go around the metro or travel in provinces through public transport. Although I have nothing against commuting, I prefer bringing a car when going from point A to point B, especially when my kids are tagging along. 

This leads me to the next question: Should we go for brand new cars or second-hand or previously owned ones? 

Photo from my sister, @nanenanigan
Photo from my sister, @nanenanigan

A Tale of Two Cars: Brand New vs. Second Hand

Our “first car” was given by my husband’s grandfather. Of course, we wanted something we really own so we decided to look for “our family car.” We found tons of cars sold online and checked out second-hand stores to see if we can find something – and yes we did. 

Most people will say that brand new is the best choice for the first family car. I wasn’t worried since my husband, being the car guy, knows a lot about cars. Trusting his judgment and knowledge, I agreed. After all, there are upsides too, such as:

  1. It is cheaper. Second-hand cars will always be cheaper than brand-new counterparts. Imagine getting a decent car for less than one million?
  2. You can haggle with the price, depending on the current condition of the car. As long as the price is reasonable, haggle away. 
  3. You can get your “Dream Car,” which you were not able to purchase few years back. At a cheaper price, of course. 

However, buying previously-owned vehicles have downsides too. This includes:

  1. “As is, where is.” Have you heard of the phrase, “Caveat Emptor?” This means Buyers Beware. You get what you pay for and there is a possibility of hidden defects, which leads me to the next one. 
  2. Preventive and maintenance costs you have to pay. This could be costly too. Even if the car looks good on the outside, the car’s “defects” will start to show as you use it over time. This means spending few thousands to ensure that the car is in good condition. My husband also employed ‘preventive maintenance’ by changing important parts in the vehicle, which entails costs too.
  3. Availing a car loan is limited to a certain number of years. Banks can offer financing. However, there is an age-limit imposed on the vehicle, which is up to five years. If you are thinking of getting a 2005 model of Pajero, you might have to open the piggy bank for that. 
  4. Older cars are harder to insure. The premiums are low too.

Tips when buying second-hand:

  • Explore your options. You can check the Internet (hello Sulit) for options. 
  • Include preventive maintenance when computing for the costs of the car. 
  • Make sure to test drive the car before buying. At the same time, check the car’s current condition too. 
  • Offer a reasonable price to the seller. You can check car websites to see how much is the market value for your chosen car for a reasonable offer. 
  • Consider buying from a friend or relatives. This way, you have an idea how the car was used instead of buying from a car agent. It’s more expensive too. 
  • Have a trusted mechanic. THIS IS A MUST. 

We are happy and contented with our purchase. The car’s been with us for almost three years already and so far, so good. Of course, there are costs to maintain the car, but then again, that’s just part of owning a vehicle.

Then we decided to look for an extra car. Since the husband and I have different schedules, I have to borrow from my parents during coding days, which is no issue to them by the way. At the same time and after exploring our options, we thought it would be better to buy a brand new car.

Finally, we found a perfect car for us. It was our first time to buy a brand new car and I must say, we should’ve done it before. When it comes to buying brand-new vehicles, here are the advantages:

  1. It (ideally) comes with zero defects. The best thing about buying brand-new cars is that it is not supposed to give you a headache, at least for up to five years. 
  2. It is easier to avail of car loan. In case you cannot pay for the vehicle in cash, you can always avail of a car loan. The dealer would love it too. 
  3. Dealers offer cash discounts. It could range from P20,000 to P100,000 or more, depending on the dealer.
  4. Warranty. Dealers offer warranty such as free checkup in case of factory defects. There is Philippine Lemon Law, which strengthens consumer protection when buying brand-new cars. 
  5. Buying brand-new has freebies. This may vary from dealer to dealer. However, you can get freebies like free tint, car matting, LTO registration assistance, maintenance services, free bag, and the like. 
  6. It is easier to get insurance. At your option, you can get a comprehensive car insurance to insure the car of any disaster. 

On the other hand, buying a brand-new vehicle comes with disadvantages too. These are: 

  1. It is more expensive. Whether you pay in cash or avail of a car loan, a brand-new vehicle is definitely more expensive, well at least depending on the car. 
  2. It is prone to car theft. In Filipino, “mainit sa mata.” 
  3. The so-called “New Car Syndrome.” Since the car is new and there is a need for break-in, there is a tendency to be slow when driving. Apparently, the phrase “slowly but surely” is not absolutely applicable when driving. 
  4. It is harder to haggle. Dealers are firm when it comes to giving discounts.

Given the pros and cons of buying brand new or second-hand vehicles, here are tips you need to remember before making a purchase: 

  • Look into all options. There are tons of cars available. Ask recommendations from friends or relatives, check out car magazines, and maximize the World Wide Web for options. 
  • Remember: “Value for Money.” This is why it is important to do research before making a purchase. Imagine paying for 1.5 million worth of crossover when you can get 1.3 million worth of SUV? Make sure to look into the car’s specification as well to know what you are getting at a given amount. 
  • Think long-term. You have to look past the exterior and think of the long-term. This includes how you will use the vehicle, life expectancy of the vehicle, maintenance costs, and oil consumption among others. 
  • The parking space. One of the important things you need to consider as well is your parking area. Do you have a sufficient parking space? Otherwise, where will you park your vehicle? 

The bottom line is explore all possible options before buying a vehicle. Buying  brand-new or second vehicle comes with pros and cons, which you all have to take into consideration. The bottom line is choose a family car wisely. 

29 Comments

  1. Kimberley Reyes (@ektreyes)

    January 7, 2016 at 12:33 am

    We own a first-hand car, but only because the payment options are friendlier. However, if we had money to pay in full, we would have gone for cars sold in auctions. We checked out one auction that sold almost brand new cars at a lower price point. The only catch is it has to be paid in full. We’ll look into that option come the time to buy a new car.

    1. Ayi

      January 7, 2016 at 4:46 pm

      Buying a car can be quite pricey too, whether it’s brand new or previously-owned one. I think the most important thing to consider also is the ability to pay. I haven’t tried looking at car auctions though. How was the experience, by the way? ๐Ÿ™‚

  2. Louisa Mercado

    January 8, 2016 at 3:34 pm

    We went for a second hand car but hopefully our next buy will be for a brand new one.

  3. MommyPehpot

    January 9, 2016 at 1:13 pm

    I’d go for brand new any time. Less hassle and less stress.. un lang magastos when you have to break in haha

    1. Ayi

      January 9, 2016 at 1:24 pm

      I know what you mean! :))

  4. msbolin

    January 9, 2016 at 2:22 pm

    We preferred the brand new and now its been with us for about three years. My mom plans to sell it to buy a new one. She reasons “para di malaspag.”

    With our second purchase, my mom works for an insurance company so we were able to get a tip re a total wrecked car for bidding. We got the car and is now with our favorite motor shop undergoing overhaul. Mas mura kapag total wrecked but make sure harap lang ang sira and the motor is all working at di nadamage. Plus, that car is almost brand new pa talaga, nabangga lang nung korean girl na may-ari before sa poste. Malakas lang loob namin to buy it because we have a trusted motor shop.

    1. Ayi

      January 10, 2016 at 12:04 am

      Hello ๐Ÿ™‚ We haven’t considered buying cars from auction, although that would be another option. Thanks for your input!

  5. rollcoastermom

    January 10, 2016 at 3:32 pm

    There are definitely a lot of things to consider in terms of purchasing vehicles. Ours is secondhand but we didn’t purchase it. It was a hand-me-down from my in-laws so we didn’t really need to think about anything much. Haha!

  6. sarah tirona

    January 11, 2016 at 2:22 am

    been personally going through the same dilemma but now im looking into long term lease, seems less hassle ๐Ÿ™‚

  7. Rowena Wendy Lei ๆž—้œฒ่–‡ (@animetric)

    January 11, 2016 at 3:03 am

    We use our cars for 10 years so a new one would be worth it for us.

  8. Mhaan Arambulo (@momyrockinstyle)

    January 11, 2016 at 3:16 am

    Whenever I ask hubby and Father-in-Law about this, they keep telling me to buy a brand new car, hassle free daw.

  9. Meikah Ybaรฑez-Delid (@Meikah)

    January 11, 2016 at 4:23 am

    Well, it all depends on your budget, really. ๐Ÿ™‚ If you can afford it, a brand new one is always a good option. Drive safely! ๐Ÿ™‚

  10. den

    January 11, 2016 at 8:50 am

    E and I are also thinking about buying a car, although not any time soon this post is really helpful in time when we have to decide whether we get a new one or a second hand one.

  11. mommy madz

    January 11, 2016 at 9:01 am

    I think it depends on the condition of the second hand car.If it was rarely used then a second hand car is a good buy if you have a limited budget.

  12. Jackie Park

    January 11, 2016 at 2:40 pm

    Thank you! This is very helpful for me ๐Ÿ™‚

  13. Maan Laxa

    January 12, 2016 at 3:04 am

    I am actually looking into buying my first car this year. My boyfriend knows a lot about cars, so secondhand shouldn’t have been a problem, but he’s planning to go abroad — and I don’t know the first thing about cars. Maybe brand new should be the way to go now unless I find a trusty mechanic.

  14. May Ann C. Anorico

    January 12, 2016 at 9:07 am

    This article is very helpful for those who wants to buy a car.

  15. celin mendoza

    January 13, 2016 at 5:38 am

    It has been a year now that me and husband are planning to buy a new car. Pero wala pa budget huhuhu. But will definitely put your tips in my mind. =)

  16. Mrs Martinez

    January 18, 2016 at 6:33 am

    We had a second hand and a brand new car. Both served us well. I wish you the best in choosing the right car.

    Xoxo
    MrsMartinez

  17. Jen Villanueva

    January 20, 2016 at 3:56 am

    Great article sis. Very informative and useful. I’ve been contemplating on this last month.. This post will truly help. Thanks!

  18. Made It Through Mum

    January 20, 2016 at 5:10 am

    If only we have that much moolah. We would buy brand new. 5 yrs ago, we bought a second hand car from a friend, you know the trust is there but then we ended up selling it again due to many issues. Im no car expert and so is my hubby. Next time hopefully, if we will buy we’ll ask a car expert’s help ๐Ÿ™‚ thank you for this article. This will definitely help us.

  19. Teresa Gumap-as Dumadag

    January 21, 2016 at 12:06 am

    This is a god article comparing the two options. My husband and I always choose brand new every time we buy. It’s cheaper in the long run because maintenance cost is lower. But sometimes you can also find good value second hand vehicles. Good luck in your search.

  20. Grace

    January 22, 2016 at 1:59 pm

    oh believe me, buying a new car is better than getting a used car. our first car was really a pain in the behind. tons of things needed to repaired and even cost us around P60k to get things fixed. then we decided to sell it and get a new one instead.

  21. mumwrites (@vixquips)

    February 6, 2016 at 4:11 am

    if you had the budget, it is best to opt for a brand new car. i agree that a car is not really much of an investment, but the comfort you get traveling in your car is really priceless iif you compare it to the hassles of commuting in the Philippines

  22. Patty | MrsC

    February 9, 2016 at 3:25 am

    We’ve experienced buying a second hand car and a brand new one. I don’t think that I will ever go back to buying second hand. There’s just too many problems that come with it. I feel like it’s really for people who enjoy tinkering with vehicles, like my dad, who has bought only one new car in all of his 60 years (his garage is filled with restored cars.)

    1. Ayi

      February 9, 2016 at 4:25 pm

      I couldn’t agree more. Although our second hand car is not exactly a “sakit ng ulo,” syempre kailangan parin ng maintenance.

  23. Maria Teresa Figuerres

    February 15, 2016 at 12:42 am

    Thanks for these tips! They will surely come in handy when we finally decide to buy our own family car.

I Would Love to Hear from You :)